New York (US-NY)
Rules, fixed strings, exclusions, retention floors and fact keys of the US-NY pack, version 2026-11-21 (research draft).
A pack records which rules Esign Comply applied. It is not a statement that a flow meets the law of this jurisdiction.
Research draft: this pack has not yet been reviewed by counsel admitted in the jurisdiction. Until that review, U.S. state packs run in test mode only.
- Code
- US-NY
- Version
- 2026-11-21
- Effective
- 2026-11-21
- Review state
- research draft
- Status
- active
- Parent pack
- US-FED (applied with this pack, reason base)
- Prompt block
- us.state.ny
- API
- GET /v1/jurisdictions/US-NY
US-44 and section 9.5 already apply New York's Electronic Signatures and Records Act (ESRA) and its exclusions. This pack adds a signature-to-record link check, automatic-renewal disclosures and notice windows (GBL § 527-a), the New York City cancellation rule, employment and freelance contract formalities, and a state-court records certification (CPLR 3122-a). Consumer, employee and resident-data rows use signer_region; contract-form rows use governing_law; evidence wording uses forum. A New York choice-of-law clause alone does not fire the renewal rows.
Coverage
Covered
- esign statute
- evidence
- online assent
- attribution
- auto renewal
- payment
- cancellation
- pricing
- language
- employment
- copies
- evidence wording
- privacy capture
- sector routing
- exclusions
- retention
Not covered
- ny 15 sector ceremonies
- billing and refunds
- sending statutory notices
- physical fulfillment
- notarization
- electronic will route
No difference from US-FED: no general consumer e-consent rule, no rule that a person must use an electronic signature, no click format for jury or class waivers, no retention floor for ordinary contracts or under § 527-a.
A pack covers selected rules, not every law in that state or country. The record identifies what was applied. Your team is responsible for legal review and for building and sending post-signing notices.
Rules
Each rule is split into parts, and each part has one class. Only record conditions (Block, Warn) can affect a session, and only after the profile has adopted them. See Jurisdiction packs and Guidance and adoption.
Signature linked to the pinned record
Esign Comply keeps each signature event linked to the pinned record version in transit and storage, and re-checks the link on export. Evidence reports and certificates never call Esign Comply a certification authority. The regulation states this rule for government transactions; applying it to private ones is an inference, for counsel confirmation.
- Triggers
- governing_law
- Scope
- NY-governed signatures and records
- Implemented in
- US-02, US-44
Esign Comply records or checks
- Service
Esign Comply keeps each signature event linked to the pinned record version in transit and storage, and re-checks the link on export. Evidence reports and certificates never call Esign Comply a certification authority.
Recommendations
- Recommendation
Ask counsel whether the government-transaction linkage standard applies to private transactions; treat it as a safeguard pending confirmation.
Legal sources STT § 304(2); 9 NYCRR §§ 540.2, 540.4
Terms updates and proxy clicks
For a terms update, the prompt asks for advance notice and a blocking screen with a checkbox and a confirm button. In proxy flows, the API warns if someone other than the account holder is treated as bound by the holder's click, and records who acted (inference, for counsel confirmation).
- Triggers
- governing_law
- Scope
policy_ack,account_signup, guest or proxy flows- Implemented in
- US-18, US-34
Esign Comply records or checks
- Warn
In proxy flows, the API warns if someone other than the account holder is treated as bound by the holder's click, and records who acted (
assisted.operator_id,assisted.authority_basis).
Recommendations
- Recommendation
Give advance notice of updated terms and require a checkbox and confirmation. Identify who clicked in proxy flows; ask counsel before treating another person as bound.
Renewal terms before consent or billing
The API refuses to seal unless the captured screen shows the ny.renewal terms clearly, next to the consent control, before consent or any billing request. Esign Comply repeats the recorded terms in its receipt; the seller remains responsible for promptly providing the required retainable notice.
- Triggers
- signer_region
- Scope
- Consumer;
one_time_purchase,auto_renewal,free_trial; not the entities exempted by § 527-a(4) - Implemented in
- US-20, CR-10, SR-7, section 12.8
Esign Comply records or checks
- Block
- Service
Esign Comply repeats the recorded terms in its receipt.
Your obligations
- Obligation
Seller: clearly disclose material renewal terms next to consent before requesting consent or billing information, obtain affirmative consent before charging, and promptly provide retainable notice of terms, charges, timing, and cancellation.
Duty holder: Seller
What you can send us
- Report
The seller may send its own evidence of the retainable notice it provided (
notice.sent). Esign Comply seals it on receipt as customer-supplied material and does not verify it.Supplement types: notice.sent
Legal sources GBL § 527 (clear and conspicuous); GBL § 527-a(1)(a)-(c)
Cancellation as easy as signup
The prompt asks for cancellation at any time, as easy as signup, in the same medium and in every medium used for consent. After in-person signup, offer online or telephone cancellation, plus in-person where practical. Retention offers must not obstruct or delay cancellation.
- Triggers
- signer_region
- Scope
- Consumer;
auto_renewal,free_trial - Implemented in
- US-20, section 12.8
Your obligations
- Obligation
Seller: offer equally easy cancellation anytime in every consent medium; for in-person signup, add online or telephone cancellation and similar in-person cancellation where practical. Do not obstruct or unreasonably delay cancellation.
Duty holder: Seller
What you can send us
- Report
The seller may send its own evidence of each cancellation request it received (
cancellation.requested). Esign Comply seals it on receipt as customer-supplied material and does not verify it.Supplement types: cancellation.requested
Legal sources GBL § 527-a(1)(d), (d-1), (e)
Renewal and trial-end charge notices
The prompt asks for notices with cancellation instructions in the consumer's chosen channel. If the first paid term is 1 year or more and renews for 6 months or more, send it 15 to 45 days before the cancel deadline. For a trial longer than one month, send it 3 to 21 days before the first charge deadline.
- Triggers
- signer_region
- Scope
- Consumer;
auto_renewal,free_trial - Implemented in
- US-20, section 12.8
Your obligations
- Obligation
Seller: send charge notices with cancellation instructions via the consumer's chosen channel: 15-45 days before cancel-by for initial paid terms ≥1 year renewing ≥6 months; 3-21 days before first cancel-by for trials >1 month.
Duty holder: Seller
What you can send us
- Report
The seller may send its own evidence of each notice it sent (
notice.sent). Esign Comply seals it on receipt as customer-supplied material and does not verify it.Supplement types: notice.sent
Legal sources GBL § 527-a(1)(f), (h) (text as revised Nov. 7, 2025)
Material-change and price-increase notices
The prompt asks for notice of a material change, including a price increase, 5 business days to 30 days before it. Before charging a higher price, the business either gets affirmative consent or allows cancellation for at least 14 days after the charge with a prorated refund. New consent is a new assent.
- Triggers
- signer_region
- Scope
- Consumer;
auto_renewal, price or term change - Implemented in
- US-18, US-20
Your obligations
- Obligation
Seller: give clear material-change notice via the chosen channel 5 business days to 30 days beforehand; obtain affirmative consent before charging more or allow at least 14 days after charging to cancel with prorated refund.
Duty holder: Seller
Recommendations
- Recommendation
Record fresh price consent as a new assent.
What you can send us
- Report
The seller may send its own evidence of each material-change notice it sent and each cancellation request it received (
notice.sent,cancellation.requested). Esign Comply seals it on receipt as customer-supplied material and does not verify it.Supplement types: notice.sent, cancellation.requested
Legal sources GBL § 527-a(1)(b-1), (g)
NYC online cancellation after in-person signup
From Oct. 1, 2026, after in-person signup by a New York City consumer, the prompt requires an online cancellation method such as a website or email; telephone alone is not enough. The seller may report the first cancellation attempt separately because it can affect restitution; Esign Comply seals the seller's assertion at receipt and does not verify the attempt.
- Triggers
- signer_region
- Scope
- Consumer;
signer.locality= NYC - Implemented in
- US-20, section 12.8
Your obligations
- Obligation
Seller: offer an online cancellation method after in-person NYC signup; telephone alone is insufficient.
Duty holder: Seller
Recommendations
- Recommendation
Keep the consumer's first cancellation attempt distinct in customer records, since it can affect restitution.
What you can send us
- Report
The seller may report the consumer's first cancellation attempt separately because it can affect restitution (
cancellation.requested). Esign Comply seals the seller's assertion at receipt and does not verify the attempt.Supplement types: cancellation.requested
Legal sources 6 RCNY §§ 5-110.1(d), 5-110.2, 5-110.3
Renewal-clause notice for service contracts and leases
For property service contracts and personal-property leases renewing for more than one month, the prompt requires written notice of the renewal clause 15 to 30 days before the deadline. Service contracts use personal or certified-mail delivery; leases use personal delivery or mail. Software subscriptions are not assumed covered.
- Triggers
- governing_law
- Scope
- Covered property service contracts and personal-property leases
- Implemented in
- US-20, section 12.8
Recommendations
- Recommendation
To preserve a covered renewal clause, give written notice 15-30 days before the deadline: personally or by certified mail for service contracts; personally or by mail for leases. Confirm software coverage with counsel.
What you can send us
- Report
The customer may send its own evidence of each written notice of the renewal clause it gave (
notice.sent). Esign Comply seals it on receipt as customer-supplied material and does not verify it.Supplement types: notice.sent
Legal sources GOL § 5-901; GOL § 5-903
Plain language, type size and arbitration clauses
The prompt asks for consumer and residential lease agreements in plain language with captions, printable at 8 points or more (5.5 points for capitals). It also says not to put a mandatory arbitration clause in a consumer-goods contract and to refer that to counsel.
- Triggers
- governing_law
- Scope
- Consumer and residential lease documents
- Implemented in
- CR-06, section 12.8
Your obligations
- Obligation
Seller or lessor: write covered agreements in ordinary language with appropriate captions. Seller: omit mandatory arbitration clauses as defined in covered consumer-goods contracts where § 399-c applies.
Duty holder: Seller or lessor
Recommendations
- Recommendation
Use legible print at least 8 points deep (5.5 points for capitals). Ask counsel whether the state arbitration restriction applies to the contract.
Legal sources GOL § 5-702 (up to $250,000); CPLR 4544; GBL § 399-c
Hiring wage notice acknowledgment
For a hiring wage notice, the API refuses to seal without the employee's dated ny.wage_acknowledgment. The prompt asks for the notice in English and the employee's primary language.
- Triggers
- signer_region
- Scope
- Employee;
employmentwage notice - Implemented in
- RT-10, section 12.8
Esign Comply records or checks
- Block
For a hiring wage notice, the API refuses to seal without the employee's dated
ny.wage_acknowledgment.Checks: CR-20Adds steps: acknowledgment.capturedStrings: ny_wage_acknowledgment
Your obligations
- Obligation
Employer: give the hiring wage notice in English and the employee's primary language, subject to statutory language exceptions, and obtain a signed, dated written acknowledgment.
Duty holder: Employer
What you can send us
- Report
The employer may send its own evidence that the wage notice was given (
wage_notice.delivered). Esign Comply seals it on receipt as customer-supplied material and does not verify it.Supplement types: wage_notice.delivered
Legal sources Labor Law § 195(1)
Commission terms and freelance contract copies
The prompt requires commission terms signed by both parties, covering pay calculation, draw reconciliation and termination pay. The customer must furnish the required signed copy to a wholesale sales representative and obtain a signed receipt, and must furnish the written contract to the freelance worker. Esign Comply records its own copy delivery where used; outside delivery may be reported by the customer as an assertion.
- Triggers
- signer_region
- Scope
- Employee and contractor;
employment,contract - Implemented in
- US-29, RT-10
Esign Comply records or checks
- Service
Esign Comply records its own copy delivery where used.
Your obligations
- Obligation
Employer: obtain mutually signed commission terms specifying calculation, draw reconciliation, and termination pay; give wholesale representatives a signed copy and obtain signed receipts. Hiring party: provide freelancers a copy of the required written contract.
Duty holder: Employer
What you can send us
- Report
The customer may report outside delivery of a signed copy or written contract as an assertion (
copy.delivered). Esign Comply seals it on receipt as customer-supplied material and does not verify it.Supplement types: copy.delivered
Legal sources Labor Law § 191(1)(c); Labor Law § 191-b; GBL § 1412
CPLR 2106 affirmation and certification notice
Provide only a signed CPLR 2106 affirmation for the applicable business-record certification. The litigant handles notice at least 30 days before trial or hearing; objections are due no later than 10 days before. CPLR 4539(b) does not apply to born-digital records. The First Department accepted a certificate and audit log without a vendor affidavit for the initial arbitration showing.
- Triggers
- forum
- Scope
- NY evidence request
- Implemented in
- US-38, US-41, CERT-13, section 9.8.8
Esign Comply records or checks
- Service
Esign Comply provides only a signed CPLR 2106 affirmation for the applicable business-record certification. It does not rely on CPLR 4539(b), which does not apply to born-digital records.
Your obligations
- Obligation
Proponent: when offering records under CPLR 3122-a, give notice and specify where inspection is available at least 30 days before trial or hearing.
Duty holder: Proponent
Recommendations
- Recommendation
If objecting to admission by certification, raise the grounds by the 10-day deadline; ask counsel about the ordinary foundation or other available exceptions.
What you can send us
- Report
The proponent may send its own evidence of the notice it gave (
notice.sent). Esign Comply seals it on receipt as customer-supplied material and does not verify it.Supplement types: notice.sent
Covered minors: minimal capture and consent
For signers flagged as covered minors, the SDK minimises device capture. The prompt asks for strictly necessary data only, or separate informed consent with refusal most prominent. Exports mask credentials and omit raw biometrics (product policy, inference, for counsel confirmation).
- Triggers
- signer_region
- Scope
- Covered users 13 and older; users 12 and younger follow COPPA
- Implemented in
- PRV-3, PRV-4, SDK capture switches
Esign Comply records or checks
- Service
For signers flagged as covered minors (
minor.covered), the SDK minimises device capture. Exports mask credentials and omit raw biometrics (product policy, inference, for counsel confirmation).
Your obligations
- Obligation
Operator: for covered users 13 and older, process data only as strictly necessary for permitted purposes or with informed consent; requested consent must be separate and make refusal the most prominent option.
Duty holder: Operator
Recommendations
- Recommendation
Treat masked credentials and omission of raw biometrics as safeguards; confirm any application beyond the statute's defined scope with counsel.
What you can send us
- Report
The operator may send its own evidence of a consent it obtained (
consent.obtained). Esign Comply seals it on receipt as customer-supplied material and does not verify it.Supplement types: consent.obtained
Legal sources GBL § 899-ff; GBL § 899-aa
NYC biometric signage for in-person flows
For biometric identification at a New York City shop, such as a kiosk, the prompt requires a sign near every customer entrance and forbids selling the data. A web notice does not replace the sign.
- Triggers
- signer_region
- Scope
signer.locality= NYC; in-person kiosk flows- Implemented in
- SDK capture switches
Your obligations
- Obligation
Covered commercial establishment: post clear biometric disclosures near every customer entrance; do not sell or otherwise trade biometric identifier information for value.
Duty holder: Covered commercial establishment
What you can send us
- Report
The establishment may send its own evidence that the sign was posted (
sign.posted). Esign Comply seals it on receipt as customer-supplied material and does not verify it.Supplement types: sign.posted
Legal sources NYC Admin. Code § 22-1202 (Local Law 3 of 2021)
Regulated sectors outside the generic flow
The wizard warns that the generic flow does not handle door-to-door sales, health clubs, retail instalment contracts, insurance, government-agency transactions or gift certificates.
- Triggers
- signer_region, governing_law
- Scope
- Regulated sector or agency flow
- Implemented in
- SS-6, section 9.5
Esign Comply records or checks
- Warn
The wizard warns that the generic flow does not handle door-to-door sales, health clubs, retail instalment contracts, insurance, government-agency transactions or gift certificates. A session marked as one of these flows carries the warning (SP-5).
Fixed strings
Wording served in required_strings[] when its rule fires. Render verbatim strings exactly; fill every element of an element list.
ny.renewal · prompt block us.state.ny
- Product or service description
- amount charged
- frequency of charges
- date or frequency by which to cancel
- cancellation mechanisms
- for trials or temporary prices, how and when the price changes and the later price
Legal sources GBL § 527-a(1)(a)
ny.wage_acknowledgment · prompt block us.state.ny
- Signed and dated receipt of the notice
- the employee's statement that they identified their primary language accurately and that the notice was in that language or otherwise complied with § 195(1)(c)
Legal sources Labor Law § 195(1)(a)
New York custodian affirmation · prompt block us.state.ny
I affirm this ___ day of ______, ____, under the penalties of perjury under the laws of New York, which may include a fine or imprisonment, that the foregoing is true, except as to matters alleged on information and belief and as to those matters I believe it to be true, and I understand that this document may be filed in an action or proceeding in a court of law.
- signature
Legal sources CPLR 2106
Exclusions
A blocked category returns 422 document_type_excluded at session creation. A warning category proceeds and the warning is recorded.
| Category | Treatment | Rule | Legal sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| New York (ESRA § 307): powers of attorney, orders-not-to-resuscitate consents, other documents appointing a fiduciary or disposing of person or property on death or incompetence (with the statute's listed exceptions); negotiable instruments and instruments of title unless handled under ESRA's rulesUS-NY/esra-307 | blocked | US-44 |
Retention floors
| Rule | What is kept | Floor | Legal sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| NY-10 | Wage-notice acknowledgments (NY-10) | Six years (employer duty; see SP-4) | |
| NY-11 | Commission salesperson terms and freelance contracts (NY-11): signed commission terms | Three years for signed commission terms; six years for freelance contracts (hiring-party duty; see SP-4) | |
| NY-11 | Commission salesperson terms and freelance contracts (NY-11): freelance contracts | Three years for signed commission terms; six years for freelance contracts (hiring-party duty; see SP-4) |
Fact keys
Keys this pack reads from context.facts. Facts are asserted by you, sealed in the record and not verified by Esign Comply.
| Key | Type | Read by | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| document_category | enum | NY-10, NY-11, NY-15 | Customer-declared document category. It narrows the Scope of state rules, feeds the exclusion screen and marks sector rows (section 9.8.9).employment | noncompete | commission_plan | wage_notice | monitoring_notice | freelance_contract | entity_governance | stockholder_consent | loan_commitment | telemarketing_consent | home_solicitation | telephone_sale | confession_of_judgment | release | indemnity | dtpa_waiver | medical_authorization | insurance_edelivery | computer_information | other |
| subscription.initial_term_days | number | NY-03, NY-04, NY-05, NY-06, NY-07, NY-08 | Initial term, in days. |
| subscription.renewal_term_days | number | NY-03, NY-04, NY-05, NY-06, NY-07, NY-08 | Renewal term, in days. |
| subscription.trial_days | number | NY-03, NY-04, NY-05, NY-06, NY-07, NY-08 | Length of the free gift or trial, in days. |
| subscription.promo_days | number | NY-03, NY-04, NY-05, NY-06, NY-07, NY-08 | Length of the promotional price period, in days. |
| subscription.price | number | NY-03, NY-04, NY-05, NY-06, NY-07, NY-08 | Price charged. |
| subscription.post_trial_price | number | NY-03, NY-04, NY-05, NY-06, NY-07, NY-08 | Price after the trial or promotion ends. |
| subscription.cancel_by | date | NY-03, NY-04, NY-05, NY-06, NY-07, NY-08 | ISO date by which to cancel. |
| subscription.signup_channel | enum | NY-03, NY-04, NY-05, NY-06, NY-07, NY-08 | How the signer signed up: online, phone or in_person.online | phone | in_person |
| subscription.service_contract | boolean | NY-03, NY-04, NY-05, NY-06, NY-07, NY-08 | Boolean: the customer marks the contract as a service contract. |
| subscription.total_value | number | NY-03, NY-04, NY-05, NY-06, NY-07, NY-08 | Total value of the contract. |
| assisted.operator_id | string | NY-02 | String: who acted for the account holder in an assisted or proxy flow. |
| assisted.authority_basis | string | NY-02 | String: the basis of that person's authority to act. |
| minor.covered | boolean | NY-13 | Boolean: the signer is flagged as a covered minor. |
| in_person_service | boolean | NY-14 | Boolean: the flow runs in person, such as a kiosk in a shop. |
Evidence wording
Selected with wording when a certificate is requested. It changes the wording of the statement only, never the ceremony rules.
Forum: New York
- Rule
- NY-12
- Authentication
- No analogue to FRE 902(13) and (14). § 4539(b) is a narrower rule for image reproductions of hard-copy originals.
- Business records
- CPLR 4518; CPLR 3122-a. For § 3122-a, state authority, accuracy after reasonable inquiry, ordinary-course timing and practice. For subpoena returns, address completeness or omissions.
- Declaration form
- Use only a signed CPLR 2106 affirmation. For § 3122-a, state authority, accuracy after reasonable inquiry, ordinary-course timing and practice. For subpoena returns, address completeness or omissions. Closing words: "I affirm this ___ day of ______, ____, under the penalties of perjury under the laws of New York, which may include a fine or imprisonment, that the foregoing is true, except as to matters alleged on information and belief and as to those matters I believe it to be true, and I understand that this document may be filed in an action or proceeding in a court of law." Follow with signature.
- Timing wording
- at the time of the act, transaction, occurrence or event, or within a reasonable time thereafter
- Notice reminder
- Give notice and inspection location at least 30 days before trial or hearing. Objections are due no later than 10 days before.
- Notes
- Analogue to FRE 902(13) and (14): No. § 4539(b) is a narrower rule for image reproductions of hard-copy originals. What the statement must not claim there: A born-digital agreement requires a vendor affidavit or § 4539(b) foundation; an audit trail alone proves who signed. Limit in this version (California and New York): Do not turn their scoped production procedures into a generic certification for every record. Arrange a witness if outside those procedures or if the other party raises a foundation challenge that requires one (Evid. Code §§ 1560-1562, CPLR 3122-a).
Legal sources CPLR 4518; CPLR 3122-a; CPLR 2106; CPLR 4539; Knight (N.Y. 2024); Sanchez (1st Dept. 2025)
Sources watched
- STT § 304
- STT § 307
- 9 NYCRR Part 540 (ESRA regulation)
- GBL § 527
- GBL § 527-a
- 6 RCNY §§ 5-110.1(d), 5-110.2, 5-110.3
- GOL § 5-901
- GOL § 5-903
- GOL § 5-702
- CPLR 4544
- GBL § 399-c
- Labor Law § 195
- Labor Law § 191
- Labor Law § 191-b
- GBL § 1412
- CPLR 3122-a
- CPLR 4518
- CPLR 2106
- GBL § 899-ff
- GBL § 899-aa
- NYC Admin. Code § 22-1202 (Local Law 3 of 2021)
- Personal Property Law § 428
- GBL § 624
- Personal Property Law § 402
- DFS electronic signature guidance (2020)
- GBL § 396-i
Initial version.